HomeMy WebLinkAboutCouncil Packet - 5/13/2019Council Work Session
May 13, 2019
Time indicated below
Harold E. Getty Council Chambers
Roll Call.
Approval of Agenda, as proposed or amended.
4:20 p.m. Update on a regional waste water treatment plant.
Submitted By: Steve Hoambrecker, Waste Management Services Director
Approx. Update on the Waste Management Biogas Project.
4:45 p.m.
Submitted By: Steve Hoambrecker, Waste Management Services Director
ADJOURNMENT
Kelley F elchle
City Clerk
CITY OF WATERLOO
Council Communication
Update on a regional waste water treatment plant.
City Council Meeting: 5/13/2019
Prepared: 5/8/2019
REVIEWERS:
Department Reviewer Action Date
Ws te Management e che, Kelley Approve . /8/2 ( 11. � A
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
D Presentation 1:3ack p
SUBJECT:
Submitted by:
Recommended Action:
Summary Statement:
Expenditure Required:
Source of Funds:
Policy Issue:
Alternative:
Background Information:
Update on a regional waste water treatment plant.
Submitted By: Steve Hoambrecker, Waste Management Services Director
u
11111111 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
111111111111
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
1,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
11111111111
1111,111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111,1,L,.„
11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,1111111111"
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
1,,,,,,,,,,,,„„„„„„„11111111111111111111111111111.1.1.1.1.1.1
1111111 11111111111111'
11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11,11
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111,
1,1111,11,11 ..qq!.111,
11111111'111111111111111111111111,,,,,111111111111111111"
111111111
1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
„.iil:,,,,,,,,,,,,1:1:1:1:1:11111111111111111111111111111111111,,,,,„
11111111111111111111111111•0 "1111111
00011111111111111111111111111111111111111111
111111111111
111111111111111111...„
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
1111 11111111111
111111111111
11111111111111111,1,,_4
1111i111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
11.1111.
II '
0
1,11111,1
(i)
1111
1111„„„Iwwwwwwwwwww„„„„,
0
'
mmt
w
, 111111111
03) C
•iJ 8470
03 4J
73 cu
Q
D -aN
i
03 ca
V VI
. L V)
O c'
v
-1—) (1) •i
i cu
v)
0
0 -oU
i
ca
0 s
cc (I)
Z
A
September 2016
M
N
01 00
r -I r -I
bia 0
= N
647/
M .1
0-
13 Qa
2 13
o 4 -i
V v)W 4-1
Q c
co
13-
U M
M E
i 0
= (20
O CU
U CC
✓Study has been completed
✓Brief Update Presented today
O
.47.toL
cp.
w
L
6L
kl
CI)
.11
r0
Iii.
0
0
L.%
0
ma
0:1)
CU
Z
v)
-0
s_ cu
CU CU
(1) 0 ..
� cin ci.
> .
4.-J 0
0 _c L%
4—) .cuu V _,
fu
03
. =
41
a) 0 cu c .,,f)
0 cr3
v, 4.,
>•
.0 u
L. 4-
0 CU
7) CD
= .
0
. tn
_C
CD >% +a 0
-Y) tn = 03
>%v) N CD
—0 e>% cla —0 4—
U . U =
CZ3 0
= .-I—)
•I)
V) —C = —C (I)
U UCU a--'
13. (T) 73
" .0
0
>%
s_
v
O O —C ttO
—0
4—)
O O
C /3 t)D —0
• t -I--J
CU
CU —0
cu ,_
cu E -a
cu
c cu = cu .
cu -I—) co 0 4—J
W0>-
0(1)0 �
1
costs for each city
ustrated projected capita
• • • • • •
' � Ir""^uuIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIG
!Il 1111) llllllllll�lllllii 0
+iiwu m'
11P�I����IIIIIIIIII��IV��Y��������d�"'V16NYI"��r�EIHYOU �ti7�hul�Gd�
i!l111!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!/,,,ljjjjjjjjjjjjll
wWwwwwwwWpWaWaIMWaWaIM
MMMMMMM
uuuuuuuuuuuuuiuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuiiuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
�ssssssssssssliilll11))))llllllllllllllllllllliillllllllllllllllsssssiisss)))!! l
40
A0,J,6�
i
0
*(7)V
i
0
V
..in
Ti
ca
-o
ca
tto
c
.Q
E
0.
0
....7,
a,
wastewater co
vZ
ca
LLco"
-a
cu
u
0
N
GJ
Fa
0
4J
t
4..i
bo
•_
4J
0= CU
4.•N
>ftH
4../
CU
cwoE
bA 4.•
..
V" ca
2"
a.1.J
A
-a
ca
-o
0
E
>ft
ca
ix
vZ
4-•s
tv
•_cuz
cc
UJ
41
f0
-aN
co
LU
O
O
i
64..ico
.
zw
.N
co
cu
A
R3U
cs
V
CU4-•
N
i
0
N
'0
3
0
>%.4-0
• - 0
U 4-i
C13
LL
+.1
cu
i
GJ
L
1—
rus6
cu
4..iN
co0
0
'al
ca
cus
1—
A
N
GJ
'Fp
bz
'L
0
_os
to
..
a)
au
s
E
0
L
N
1Mc15ea0
accommodate
-a
0
E
>ft
co
GC
v;'
s
to
CI)2
c3
DC
W
GJ
co
-o
N
i
co
LU
VZ
of Cedar Fa
and Hudson.
c
0
' EP
ca
N
CU N
O til)
' Fi) O
cu V
DC -0
eima cu
3 owv
ow cu
s •-
:1-• o
aim
co
s
. 4mi
0
0
au
4-•
ca
•
C
0
CO
N
. —
co
i
0
. _
to
au
CC
0
-c
i
G 2
ko 00
t -i
r -I Lri
0 ko
I-1
im.
mprovements
c
0
r,
ca
�N
t
. . • t
0
IA
0
mprovements
G c
u1 O
ai
in. ko
in.
H �
O
E in
8 co > w a
•_ 1- -0 0
rq o
a=+
N co 0-N to l�i � �N
V •— i 3 CO
� � O
en N � N H
co a) •_
_c co .- to 62°
v, LL oo_ ce
i_c..- .• co > • ..t. -0I CU IU I
•
2
0
I.A
c
. _
co
E
0)
V
i
0
c
0
'4=
ca
4
J
N
c
. _
4/1
ca
co
Cf
W
.
-0
c
0
Eco
ce
H
4 -i -c
aA
w
a -0
c 0 a)
4=.7. c
co
,N= '47. C ,O
'2 :ow
0 0
E w ccu
• OC 0 .�
4-0 rn
fa = 0
-o 2 0 ce
0 ..t. _c
..ti
RS .
> 1W
•
i
c
._
ez
E
a)
u
0
u
c
0
CO.47,
4
J
c
.—
IA
CD
m
W
•
c
0
o-0
2 1 1
c
0
Ca
N
. _
ca
C
0
. -
1213
W
CC
0
s
G
(NI
r -I
N
00
in.
a)
-o
a) a)
F47,
t
70 m
N i
CU
0 Ca 4/1
in o
.w 'Ea 5
cno w ca
V = 0
-c
. •
•
wog opdsoolq osalpaop-pue-loom.
11111110000111111
1111111111111111111111111111
111111111111 11111111'1111111,
i�
111
il lllllllllll �
100000
IIIIIIIIIIIIIII���������11100oo«����I
111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111,
c
11000lOVVIIIII111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111! 1111111111111111111100vo 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111110„„„„„0000,00000000 II 111111111111111111111111 II11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111, mmmilmmmmmmmmmmmilmmmmmmmmm11,11,11111 1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111opoopoollIvvvvoo
1111111111111111111 111111111111"mool000looloommololillitilloo
wrz
111
11111 11111
Nddddl �l
tltldddduu`
l000 00 1111111111111111111111111
i E
ca a)
a) 4-d rn
.0
so
._ � 0- 'aro
4-10 .Ec a�
E•_
C1J>4
a)
+9 4,2 °
s •—
4-3 :4 -
cu a) 0
c cu
E •ef
ai) E
a E E
oE
49 mu 8
v,
� � ta)
>4 .5 4-I
CD L5
s
co•—
w (.5
u 4-l>4 os-
ra —0 41—
:47°
s-
1:3 1:3 V a)i
i
N
0
J
ncreases
CO• a)
4-)
co
CL =
I— al
4E
LL
i
L1)
O p
.
MO O
N s—
=
CU
Q tO
13 4-0
C L
CU CU0
C CD
ca
L —
m o
0
c
ca
a
O
0
0
il0
m
Debt services wi
OO 0 O
0 0 0 0
0)
-00
E
c
ca
0
._
aA
0)
cC
c
co
c
._
r:::
0
1-i
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
IIIIIIIIII
o O o O O O
O O
-1 in -
6
O O O O O O O
00 N t0 L d- m N
CO
N
O
01
co i
cocuN
LID
L
ir
m
N
uuoypdsboli selpoop-pUe-soope;
111,11111,1
WWI
1111111,1,
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
11000000007000111111100
11111111111f�1
1I,
bolt
rlyi�IN��>��y
‚1,
VI
CU
N
-o
co
cui
oversee the
ea
0
-aa,
� 2v
3
s o
♦+ L
'05
+.0c•
E wE
cu
b.0
CU >4
ea
0
0
V
•
fa
•
fa
Ci)
co
C
O
A
• U
r0
6L
co
ea
s
0
e tTn
a)
cc
A
11111 11111 11111
111111111111
wI
0000
AAA
IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII
10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000001000100000000000000000000000000000001000000000
111111111
■tll■I
V o u HHI uuu000000i
VIVIV
111,11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
Ill000VVVihovovop000v000000000000
111111111111111111111
oo010000000000e
4J
+ .10aJ
a) -o
cu
a)
a)
-o •_
a)_o
•_
a) 64.7a
L O
co
co
•vf 1/2
a) G1
ca t
3 a o
:471
,ets(13 -0
o�
• s ca
fa
°1 et;
a�OU▪ U L (0
N CTS GJ
13 ma
aJ 4-#WUC
>. CS E
a )
V i E
c rg
W
A A A
Operating structure
A A
CITY OF WATERLOO
Council Communication
Update on the Waste Management Biogas Project.
City Council Meeting: 5/13/2019
Prepared: 5/8/2019
REVIEWERS:
Department Reviewer Action Date
ste .Man.agement &He,".1<1cH y Approved 5/8/20 1 9 I I 07r AM
ATTACHMENTS:
Description Type
D P resent ation 13 ack up M ate
SUBJECT:
Submitted by:
Recommended Action:
Summary Statement:
Expenditure Required:
Source of Funds:
Policy Issue:
Alternative:
Background Information:
Update on the Waste Management Biogas Project.
Submitted By: Steve Hoambrecker, Waste Management Services Director
8, 2019 Presentation
itt
iiiidadadadadadadoodooded,
iliii11111911111110.....""
1111111111111111 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
11111111111111111111111111111111111
11111
111111111111111
1111111111111111111111111111111
11111111111"' 111111
111111111111111111111111111114)))1
11/1/1/1/1r
"11111,111,0ggiggigiii,1,,
,,,,,,1111111"11'11"1"
1111111111
11111111111111111111111101010;01..„
•
111111111111111111111111111111111111111,
mmmm'''m11111111----
,111111111111,
""topi
11111,1,.
.01110.
11011112
1,11111.1 1811•011611
rOSINI
11
111.111E,
11111.1011111111111111111
1,1
co
"co
os.
'a
a�
L
L 'a
� V
(1)
0
3
O CP
.12
0
72 -a
o �-
-a
'a
'a
!� c �
fC � ttl
›la U
V0 11/2 cu
.F3 22
fa
wa
0 .10 3 u
� w ,U) V t
O i cs'
Ul �
Lfl 3 ULflW.
0 RI
C
\\o"
11111111111111111111111111111
'a
v
0
fw$6.0-6.7 mi
"jQ U(jIIIIIIIyIfIIfIfIIfIIqIIII I IIIIIV�"""IIIIIIII
�u,Y�N Illll�'u ii %�"I'I�� Ilu mollllll�lll����llllllllll����ll III II lu uuiiilllll V
•
111111111111,01111�
� II I'IIIIIIIHI'I IIIuuIIIIIIN+ 'SII
v IG III
14111 ��I I�
II
''Rdlllllll(IIuuIIQ,I,I��If?Illlllliiiiiiii' �,' � ���Niirh���III�IY
IIIIIIIIIIIIII � „gra �� I'I�
✓ 800,000 ft3/day
c
•
-o a)
u) a)
co c .
cp ro a)
o a) .o_ >,
io 0 a _6_,U
a) o a)
co -0 _i_J 1_
>, -o . lo
D -0 (1)
O CU (I)
V U ▪ U
c
sa)
L a)
L L
� (6
U�
co 111
.c >
V
C
0
ol0000l000000
acceptance
E
Lf�
N
4.09-
Z
1 �1� IIuIPa wY1�Nr�
�rrY�lll ii I lr
tiu�wVC
d I
°j Nllsr „
IWIIP!I''
111111111111111111
Pu.
m
.11111111111111111,
Sludge/Grease Remova
1
Www
NNI
0000000000l00000000
0000 001
1111111111111111101111
II00000000000000
olioLottn
III' VIII Vlp'� a '
l�Illll11111111111111111llllllllllll jiii
!lllllll1l�l�lllll���lllIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIii'iiiiiiiii'i'iiiii'ii'ii'ii'iiiiil�l�l�l�'�'iiiii'I
11111a1�IIIVV)IIIII�I�!Illlluilllipl;lllllllll"li�;l�y»upl I iuu,
1111111111
!
9 Ilil!ii!�I,
I, ��I113�1
� jP
111111111111111
111I�iiulu�l ll�l�llllil
�I��I,klll�
1 111 1'1'1'11111
Uii iV,III' II'
I .
11111111111111111
Ill,
II'.I{
11111111
111111111111
0
m L 2
mprovements
ta).>
413(1)
coN
(1)
2
0
0
—J
3oligM�'olq�
1111111111111.
1111111111111 0000000m00000
11111111111111111111111100
11 11(
Ili
ni
41111111,
111111111111111111111111
1,1,111,1!..1!1111,1,1,1,1,1.1111,11.111,11111111111111111111
IIII"
I j' a
000m00000000000loolool0000l 111111111
011101111111111111111111111111111111111111011111111
11111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111
ilk111111111111111111111111111111111111
E
0
N
U
6
3
O
L/�
y„6 L
cf,
i
a)
U �
o
.`(1)
N
"Ci5 \\o,
a)
i
0
s_:
tD” "
- C
J
-7
Ca
ncludes new fences and access
gates for site security
FOG Receiving System
Screens trash and rocks
C13
(/)
0
Ea co
� L
o
_a
O L
o
Ca
L
-Cr)
.cT3
0)
c
c0
co
0
U
U
co
CNG or Pipeline Gas
Potential site for CNG
(f)
oE
�O
'-'0
v)
ro
(? 0
4(T3'
_ic
ized resource
._
3
wia
_ C
fa a,
a:r
4.1
a) in
4-1 w
o c
a) 1-
3 ro
C ++
CU '
dl �
L V
4.•
ro
4-1
L• cu CU
03) W W
>, E
in in
� L L
L
a 1- I—
A A A
To Best Protect
11111111111111111111111111111111
111111111011
>•
II 11111111111111111111111111111
��u'lllll'�i�x�
OIUIV,,1
1I101111 0I 1v
II 1111111'�r
; IIIIIIIIIIIIIII (1l�iiii. iii p9j�p9 iiUiiiiiiii
11 1
'oiIoNIVV�d�StiIVV
0 E
ro
Y
to
$6,700,000
O
a
1
$14,440,000
Lagoon Only
$16,340,000
cu
wia
ro
Lagoon, accepting additiona
$21,140,000
Combine 2 & 3
$23,040,000
Combine 2 & 4
$2,900,000
wia
L
ro
a
L
M
O
a
0
10.4% rate increase
Only NG Price $160,000 Revenue
2.5% rate increase
Low end Revenue
- 2.5% rate decrease
High end Revenue $1,700,000
0.0% rate adjustment
Projected Revenue $1,400,000
0.4% rate increase
Cost 100/0 Reduction
Low end Revenue
- 2.8% rate decrease
High end Revenue $1,700,000
- 0.3% rate adjustment
Projected Revenue $1,400,000
f<1
N
m
0
z
rate increase
Only NG Price $500,000 Revenue
0.4% rate increase
te decrease
- 0.3% rate decrease
- 2.4% rate decrease*
4.J
0
a)• .—..,O
L
Q
G
q..)
4
4.49
L
0
ow
0
.zL
N (1)O O � O O (n
O O �Pr 0 0
-6-)O O O O �
O 11� O I� G)O 7rO 71-'a00 O 00 O p
•- N � N C
-bn- -Ler -bn- 4d9_
O
N
tnroN
1_0
0
4:)0
N
Break even Revenue
Projected Revenue
Cost 10% Reduction
Break even Revenue
Projected Revenue
0
4-)0
z
0
w
4si
(1)
s ca
it
L
>mlw
C 4•O
op
II C Pia
0 Cam
C o a)
O � ti
:I., J a
p0,12'
0 in
L 4j
4INE c(1) W
(I:
kip E
w
0
ai L 0
12.
E
$16,340,000
Cost Preliminary Estimate
4)
cn
c0
(1)
1_
U
c
4U
c0
1_
0
N
,-i
1-i
Only NG Price $625,000 Revenue
0% rate increase
- 4.9% rate decrease
O O
O O
O O
O O
O
O Ln
14 Nj
Break even Revenue
Projected Revenue
$14,706,000
Cost 10% Reduction
- 0.8% rate decrease
- 5.8% rate decrease*
O 0
O O
O 0
O L.r)
0 d-
00 O
,-i N
Break even Revenue
Projected Revenue
4_,
0
N
..-1O
i_Q
M
1--1
1--1
-be
i_O
N
0
•_L
a)
(n
4_,
_o
a)
O
N
ricsN
1_0
N
00
00
Lri
a)
-6-)0
z
3 111
o 09
0
(5>
J O
L
in al ca.
aE
c F., 1.40 a)
14-11. iii:-;
CI.
0 o =
L
4- 0
01:17-7
(5 mo
W V
6 1'4
iii 2
$21,140,000
iminary Estimate
cu
L
a_
4-)
ui
0
U
20.3% rate increase
Only NG Price $660,000 Revenue
- 1.9% rate increase
cu
v)
- 4.4% rate decre
O o
O O
O o
L ri L. n'
i -i 71-
()r) M
4A- -Ler
Low end Revenue
Projected Revenue
$19,026,000
Cost 10% Reduction
ncrease
- 3.0% rate
- 5.5% rate decrease*
O O
O O
O O
L ri L. n'
i -i 1-
M co'
-bn- 4A
Low end Revenue
Projected Revenue
0
N
0
Q
0
i-i
L
0
U
0
4-)
szi
0
O
0
tnro0
1_0
0
00
Ln
Ln
0
4—J0
z
s
:w
II
c =
o a'
0 E
im
w o
JO
6
‘C)al im. M
N
i a E '
0 1-- N
14J 2,cl. iii
0 E
O to
it: ,O
u) ±s: (1)L-
._
IC 110
(44,9 No �
0
� � U
O •.iii
iminary Estimate
20.3% rate increase
Only NG Price $780,000 Revenue
- 5.2% rate increase
cu
v)
- 6.1% rate decre
O o
O O
O o
O O
Lnq:) N
prj M
4A- -Lek
Low end Revenue
Projected Revenue
0
0
0
q:4M
N
ncrease
- 6.4% rate
- 7.3% rate decrease*
0
N O O
-b09- O O
O O
O
L
qD0 N
M M
Cost 10% Reduction
Low end Revenue
Projected Revenue
decrease or fund debt service for $14.2M
(i)
4.•
Om
Ct. =a
IJJ
(1) 03)
E 3
3 co
o >
ti) L
(0) Q
(1)J
0
Cn
J
Natural Gas
D3 RIN Price
N
O co
00
M
M
LCFS Credits
Potential Value
0
wia
wia
w 3
L a)=
fa >
E cu
L
cp
wia
Y �
L L
O U
C
o, ISIS
1
a�
EW3
O fa
>
ate
�V
(1) ( am
W(1) ai
L (13 z U
0 mil D rY U)
X ro L.r.) u
zoo
Potential Value
4.1
V
f0
L
i0 W
u►
WI
I_ Ew
cu
4a
cn
C �
O >
— O
Q) U
� O
D 4.1
(1)
O
Vcu
L4.1cu
0
Ccn-a
ete 10-15%
Strand to comp
C
O
L �
a) a)
t 4a -0
.1.•
O fa
4.)
4.1
3
O. RI
O
a.+
L •V
W L.
i 3
E— (1)
cn (I)
0
o (I)
= W .1200 r
E
w�
M u
0.i.i
1. cu
w y O =
V0. 4.• u0
\\). L a)
u_A
Estimated Costs
revenue
Estimated Costs - $10,000
\\›
✓ Complete in 2-3 months
Estimated Costs $22,000,000
ete in 24-30 months
a
E
0
v
010
,11
�IIII���uu�glluP,;u
11,1,11111111111
11111111111111111111111111111111111111
111111111
m0000000iii000ll
IIII
111111111111,111111111111111111111111111111111111111110
H� V
111111 �I aiaiar,,,,
1111111111111111',
11111111111
111111111111111111111111111111111111
j1C1111„„„„„„„
111111111111111111111111
Go - No -Go, finish design negotiate contracts
co
-o
c
E
E
0
U
a)
co
• _
co
c
co
inal Market
• V
0
Zj%V
• V
0
(f)
1_
4-)
•
4-)
N
N
Q
V
N
O
Q
0
N
(0
Q
p411
ii,,.
111111111111111111,
■
111111,1111111111111111111111111111111
11111111111111ih
(IIll I, 1'�l�iiiiiiiiiiiii%%%J��l////�/ a
4,0»111,
.,11IIIIIIIIIIIIIIII11I
4!lllllllupuuq;
011
110000000000101
■
J
1
Go — No -Go, finish design negotiate contracts
(1)
o O
4.•
+, U
-a V
C �
0
0.0
a)
4.•
4.1
U f0
C
•
4l
inal Market
Updates of the project presented to city council
osts and initial evaluation completed on Lagoon Biogas
WWTP Cost Identified in Facility Plan
So....How Best to Achieve?
0
in-
i01 -
(1)
(i)0
s
41/0)c
I -
3.
nu w
IN 1 Ela
'UV' a)
D
0
.1.1al
I
u)w
-a
RI
Fic
1.4
-a
(1)
(1)
z