HomeMy WebLinkAbout09/23/1980 Civil Service Commission
September 23 , 1980
Chairman Braun called the meeting to order.
Members Present : Braun, Eibey, Randall
Absent : Furgerson
Also present : Roger Mogle , Jim Rodemeyer, Vic Kennedy, Junior
Grimm & Michelle Temeyer.
The purpose of the meeting was to review applicants for the positions
of Fire and Police Chiefs .
The Commission agreed to first review the seven applications for
Fire Chief. It was decided that the method of review of each would
be for each Commissioner to review each application to check for
compliance with the qualifications set out at an earlier meeting .
The application/resume process is a pass-fail system.
After review of the Fire Chief applications , it was moved by Randall ,
seconded by Eibey that all seven applications which include the names
of Edward Paganelli, Gerald Olson, Virgil Cutsforth, Stanley Stapella,
David Wickersheim, Melvin Cook & Eugene Fortune be considered as
passing the first stage of the application process , as each applicant
demonstrated the required extensive supervisory and administrative
experience. The motion carried.
The Commission then proceeded to the eighteen applications for police
chief. The method of review was for each Commissioner to review
each application to check for compliance with the qualifications set
out at an earlier meeting. The application/resume is a pass-fail
system.
After review of the Police Chief applications, it was moved by Randall ,
seconded by Eibey to fail Anthony Spagnola because he failed to
demonstrate in his resume and application the prerequisite of
experience in administration and supervision as required for the
position. The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to fail Palmer Forney
because he failed to demonstrate in his resume and application the
prerequisite of experience in administration and supervision as
required for the position. The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to fail Robert Shafer
because he failed to demonstrate in his resume and application the
prerequisite of experience in administration and supervision as
required for the position. The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to fail Robert Greenlee
because he failed to demonstrate in his resume and application the
prerequisite of experience in administration and supervision as
required for the position. The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to fail William Hermansen
because he failed to demonstrate in his resume and application the
prerequsiite of experience in administration and supervision as
required for the position. The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to fail Bill Trammell
because he failed to demonstrate in his resume and application the
prerequisite of experience in administration and supervision as
required for the position. The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to fail Harry Helgeson
because his application, resume , and attached letter did not
demonstrate the required extensive experience in supervision and
administration, and specifically, the experience which is itemized
tells only the job description and fails to specify the particular
type of experience he has had and therefore does not meet the
requirements as set out . The motion carried.
Civil Service Commission -2- September 18 , 1980
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey that the remaining applica-
tions which include the names of John Corder, Arnett Davis , C . F.
Myhr, Gil Hansen, Junior Grimm, Robert Maltas , Dennis Demon, Donald
Kehoe , Lawerence Dolan, Arthur Murray, and Roger Shook be considered
as passing the first stage of the application process , as each
applicant demonstrated the required extensive supervisory and admin-
istrative experience . The motion carried.
It was moved by Randall , seconded by Eibey to adjourn at 6 :45 P .M.
The motion carried.
Larry P . Burger , Clerk
Civil Service Commission